VATupdate

Share this post on

VATupdate Newsletter Week 47 2023

Opinions

The opinions of the Advocate General of the ECJ often provide a very interesting read. Where the ECJ mostly just focuses on the specific questions in the case, the AG’s often take the liberty to expand their thoughts and elaborate on the technicalities, as well as the social and practical implications of the questions raised by the parties. I wouldn’t call it bedtime reading, but in some cases it can be entertaining to read the ‘essays’ produced by the AG and their teams.

While the Advocate General’s opinion is not binding for the ECJ nor for the courts in the member states, their conclusions are often taken into consideration and are often indicative of the ruling by the Court of Justice in the case. Since 2020, there are eleven Advocates General appointed for six-year terms, five of whom are designated from the largest member states in the EU (Germany, France, Italy, Spain, and Poland) and the other six members are appointed between the other member states.

The first Advocate General, who is tasked with assigning the cases to her or himself or their fellow AG’s and has some powers related to judicial review of the General Court cases, is elected for a three-year term among these eleven people. Ad hoc Advocates General may also be appointed for cases before the General Court among the judges working in the court, but this possibility is not used now. An Ad Hoc AG would be useful in a very specific case, where specific knowledge or experience is required to assess a specific question or situation.

With all the VAT experts that are visiting our website, we know that many people have an opinion of specific rules and cases. Probably not always the same as the AG, or the ECJ for that matter. You can express this in an article, blog or via social media, should you want to do so. If you do, please let us know, so that we can publish it.

Here’s an opinion from a friend of mine that many people may recognize: “Of all the certainties that people so desperately need in life, I find the most reassuring to be the Tax Authorities, which really misses no opportunity to show what an unprecedentedly amateurish organization it is.”

You may or may not agree with this. Please let me know.

Have a great week!

If you have any comments, questions, or ideas that you want to share with us, please send us an email at [email protected] or leave a comment under the posts of this newsletter on LinkedIn.


To go directly to the region, click below:


WORLD

WORLD

WEBINARS / EVENTS


AFRICA

ANGOLA

CABO VERDE

EGYPT

GHANA

IVORY COAST

KENYA

MAURITIUS

SÃO TOMÉ AND PRÍNCIPE

SOUTH AFRICA


AMERICAS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

BRAZIL

CANADA

CHILE

COLOMBIA

GUATEMALA

MEXICO

PANAMA

PERU

SAINT KITTS AND NEVIS

UNITED STATES

URUGUAY


ASIA-PACIFIC

ASIA PACIFIC

ARMENIA

AUSTRALIA

AZERBAIJAN

BANGLADESH

CAMBODIA

CHINA

INDIA

JAPAN

KAZAKHSTAN

MALAYSIA

NEPAL

PAKISTAN

PHILIPPINES

SINGAPORE

SOUTH KOREA

SRI LANKA

TAIWAN

UZBEKISTAN

VIETNAM


EUROPE

EUROPE

EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE

EUROPEAN UNION

EUROPEAN UNION – ViDA

AUSTRIA

BELGIUM

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

CROATIA

CYPRUS

CZECH REPUBLIC

DENMARK

FINLAND

FRANCE

GERMANY

GREECE

ICELAND

IRELAND

ITALY

LATVIA

LITHUANIA

LUXEMBOURG

MALTA

NETHERLANDS

POLAND

PORTUGAL

ROMANIA

RUSSIA

SERBIA

SLOVAKIA

SPAIN

SWEDEN

TURKEY

UKRAINE

UNITED KINGDOM


MIDDLE EAST

GCC

BAHRAIN

ISRAEL

MIDDLE EAST

OMAN

SAUDI ARABIA

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES


 

Sponsors:

VAT news
VAT news

Advertisements: