VATupdate

Share this post on

VATupdate Newsletter Week 38 2025

DISCLAIMERS

If you buy a watch, it may say that you can swim with it. But of course, that only applies if you can already swim without it.

Life is full of these disclaimers that sound helpful but state the obvious. Coffee cups warn us that the contents may be hot. Sleeping pills caution that they may cause drowsiness. Ladders remind us not to stand on the very top rung. And then there was the man who, after surgery on his hand, asked the doctor if he would be able to play the piano. “Yes, of course,” the doctor replied. The man was delighted: he had never before managed to get anything worth listening to out of any instrument.

Watches don’t give you the ability to swim. And an operation on your hands won’t turn you into a concert pianist. VAT rules, guidance, and case law are no different. They often come with conditions that look like clarifications but, once you’ve read them, you realise they don’t really clarify much at all.

Take the classic: Input VAT may be deducted if and to the extent that the goods and services are used for taxable transactions. Stripped down, that’s basically saying: you can swim with your watch… if you already know how to swim.

Or: A supply is taxable where it is made… unless it is not. Which is about as useful as a sign on a park bench that reads: Do not sit on bench if you don’t want to sit down.

The challenge is that businesses look for certainty in VAT. But the “helpful” disclaimers often push the uncertainty back onto them. Is this supply in or out of scope? Deductible or not? Taxable where supplied, or where received? The answer is often: it depends… Hardly the solid ground you’d hope for when navigating a tax system.

The truth is that VAT rules (and their disclaimers) only really help if you already know the basics and can apply them to your facts. Much like swimming: if you don’t already know how, the warning label on your watch won’t save you.

So, in VAT as in life, read the fine print. But don’t expect it to keep you afloat. For that, you’ll need experience, judgment, and perhaps a good adviser. After all, VAT may be simple… unless it isn’t.

And if you want to avoid turning VAT into a piano recital nobody wants to hear, follow us on www.vatupdate.com. At least then you’ll be up to speed on the fine print, the details, and the headlines.

If you have any comments, questions, or ideas that you want to share with us, please send us an email at [email protected] or leave a comment under the posts of this newsletter on LinkedIn.


WORLD

WORLD

WEBINARS / EVENTS


 

MIDDLE EAST

ISRAEL

LEBANON

OMAN

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES


 

AFRICA

ANGOLA

BOTSWANA

ETHIOPIA

GHANA

KENYA

SOUTH AFRICA

TANZANIA

TUNESIA


 

AMERICAS

AMERICAS

ARGENTINA

BAHAMAS

BARBADOS

BOLIVIA

BRAZIL

CANADA

CHILE

COLOMBIA

COSTA RICA

ECUADOR

MEXICO

PARAGUAY

UNITED STATES

URUGUAY


 

ASIA-PACIFIC

AUSTRALIA

BANGLADESH

CHINA

FIJI

INDIA

JAPAN

KAZAKHSTAN

MALAYSIA

NEW ZEALAND

PAKISTAN

PHILIPPINES

SOUTH KOREA

SRI LANKA

TAIWAN

THAILAND


 

EUROPE

EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE

EUROPEAN UNION

EUROPEAN UNION – ViDA

BELGIUM

BULGARIA

CROATIA

CZECH REPUBLIC

DENMARK

FINLAND

FRANCE

GERMANY

GREECE

HUNGARY

ICELAND

IRELAND

ITALY

LATVIA

MOLDOVA

NETHERLANDS

NORTH MACEDONIA

POLAND

PORTUGAL

ROMANIA

RUSSIA

SERBIA

SLOVAKIA

SLOVENIA

SPAIN

SWEDEN

SWITZERLAND

TURKEY

UKRAINE

UNITED KINGDOM


 

 

 



Sponsors:

VATIT Compliance
Pincvision

Advertisements:

  • Basware