VAT Treatment of “Ausschlachten” and “Upcycling” Explained

• The European Court of Justice ruled that the dismantling of car parts can be subject to differential taxation.
• The question arises whether the same applies to the combination of old and new items to create something new, known as “upcycling”.
• The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) will soon have to decide on this matter.
• The Schleswig-Holstein Fiscal Court ruled that differential taxation also applies to the sale of restored antique washstands with new sink attachments.
• The BFH will have to decide whether the restoration and sale of antique furniture with new parts should be considered a single transaction or two separate transactions subject to different tax treatments.
• The argument for differential taxation is to avoid multiple taxation in the supply chain.
• However, recent decisions by the EU Court of Justice and the BFH suggest a trend towards not dividing a single economic transaction into separate services.
• It is unclear how the BFH will rule on this matter.

Source: nwb-experten-blog.de

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---