Important Ruling on VAT Margin: Sales Contracts Must Include Accurate Seller Information

• The case involves a taxpayer whose purchase of 88 cars was questioned by tax authorities.
• The cars were bought in Germany, Belgium, and Austria.
• The Supreme Administrative Court ruled that if a sales contract does not contain the actual seller’s data, the VAT margin procedure cannot be applied.
• The tax authorities have not yet proven their case, so it will be re-examined.
• According to VAT law, the VAT margin procedure can be used for used goods if the purchase was not subject to VAT or if the supplier used the same procedure.
• The taxpayer disagreed with the requirement to identify the seller by name for the VAT margin procedure.
• The tax office found inconsistencies in documents and testimonies from German taxpayers.
• The taxpayer won in the Warsaw Administrative Court, which annulled the decision due to unverified statements from German vehicle owners.

Source: podatki.gazetaprawna.pl

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---