Settlement of Historical Car Claims: Cambria Automobiles Ltd & Anr vs. HMRC

• Cambria Automobiles submitted a claim for margin scheme VAT overpaid on sales of demonstrator cars between 1973 and 1996
• HMRC agreed to pay Cambria’s claim in 2006
• The agreement extended to all overpayments in relation to the vehicles supplied by Cambria during the relevant periods
• Other car dealers negotiated additional payments based on the “Italian tables” used to calculate the claims
• Cambria’s 2009 claim breached the terms of the agreement and was rejected by HMRC
• The Upper Tribunal criticized the FTT for not applying the approach to contractual interpretation
• The Upper Tribunal reached the same conclusion as the FTT and dismissed Cambria’s appeal.

Source: taxscape.deloitte.com

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---