VAT refund rightly refused due to unproven previous payment

• Court Ruling on VAT Refund Request: The District Court of Noord-Nederland upheld the inspector’s decision to reject X’s VAT refund request of €19,999, determining that X failed to provide sufficient evidence that VAT had been paid in relation to the claimed bad debt of €91,482.
• Lack of Documentation: The inspector challenged the existence of any VAT payment and noted that X did not submit any supporting documents to substantiate the claim, which led to the inspector correcting the input tax to zero.
• 2012 Letter Not Sufficient: The court found that a letter from 2012, which outlined tax treatment agreements for income tax and previous turnover tax assessments, did not establish any legitimate expectation for a VAT refund, thereby dismissing X’s appeal as unfounded.

Source Taxlive

---

Court Confirms Denial of VAT Refund Due to Insufficient Proof of Unpaid Invoice

• The court ruled that the tax inspector rightfully denied the request for a VAT refund.
• The claimant failed to prove that the conditions for a VAT refund under Article 29 of the Dutch VAT Act were met.
• The court found no violation of the principle of legitimate expectation.
• The claimant could not provide sufficient evidence of the original invoice or that VAT had been paid on it.
• The VAT refund request was based on a decades-old claim that had become uncollectible due to statute of limitations.

Source: uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---