Tenant Electricity Supply Constitutes Independent Taxable Delivery According to Münster Tax Court

• The Münster Tax Court ruled that electricity deliveries from landlords to tenants are independent taxable supplies, not ancillary services to VAT exempt residential rentals
• This applies both to electricity generated by the landlord’s own photovoltaic system and electricity purchased from external suppliers before the PV system was operational
• The court determined these are independent taxable services when tenants can freely choose their electricity supplier and electricity is billed separately based on individual consumption
• The legal coupling prohibition in Energy Industry Act section 42a paragraph 2 supports this view, as tenant electricity contracts cannot be part of residential rental agreements
• Input services from PV system acquisition are therefore connected to taxable electricity supply rather than VAT exempt rental income, allowing input VAT deduction rights

Source: ebnerstolz.de

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---