Committee Raises Concerns Over Scottish Government’s VAT Assignment Plans

• The Scottish Parliament’s Finance and Public Administration Committee is unconvinced by VAT assignment plans.
• The evidence session on VAT Assignment featured contributions from various organizations.
• VAT assignment was proposed as part of the Scotland Act 2016.
• Concerns about how VAT receipts would be calculated led to the policy being put on hold in 2019.
• The recent Fiscal Framework Review commits both the Scottish and UK governments to finding a solution for implementing the policy.
• The Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) expressed concerns about the lack of direct control over VAT policy and the risks and complications it could bring.
• The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) described VAT as a poor candidate for devolution or assignment and suggested considering alternative taxes.
• The Fraser of Allander Institute expressed doubts about the feasibility of accurately measuring Scottish VAT receipts and warned of the unreliability of data.
• The Scottish Fiscal Commission and Audit Scotland also raised concerns about data volatility and auditing challenges.
• Cross-party concerns were expressed about the difficulties of implementing VAT assignment and the potential compliance issues.
• Some committee members were skeptical about the benefits outweighing the costs of VAT assignment.

Source: tax.org.uk

Note that this post was (partially) written with the help of AI. It is always useful to review the original source material, and where needed to obtain (local) advice from a specialist.

---

---