There is no taxable service by a fitness studio operator if the gym is closed. Neither the continued payment of membership fees nor the replacement services offered by the operator is an exchange of services subject to VAT. With this decision, the Hamburg tax court deviates from an earlier view held by the Schleswig-Holstein tax court. Both proceedings are now pending before the Supreme Tax Court for final clarification.
Source: PwC DE
Latest Posts in "Germany"
- Avoiding VAT by Withdrawing Assets Before Sale: New Legal Clarifications
- Federal Fiscal Court Rules on VAT Exemption for Private Clinics: Criteria and Mixed Outcomes Explained
- TSE Replacement in Germany: Multi-Year POS Transition, Hardware vs. Cloud, and Strategic Planning
- BFH: Foreign Businesses Can Claim Input VAT via Assessment Procedure Despite No Ongoing Domestic Sales
- Reduced VAT Rate for Collector Coins; Gold and Silver Price Announcement for 2026
