X breeds, trains and races horses.
The District Court of the Northern Netherlands ruled that X is not a VAT entrepreneur, referring to the Baštová judgment of the Court of Justice, case C-432/15. The prize money received by X cannot be regarded as consideration, as this depended on the classification of the horse.
Court of Appeal Arnhem-Leeuwarden confirmed that X does not carry out any economic activities with his horses, as the provision of a horse, with a view to that horse’s participation in a horse competition, is not a service for consideration. Indeed, this is only the case if X would already receive compensation from the organiser of the competition, regardless of the ranking of the horse on arrival at the competition.
The Supreme Court did not overrule.
Source: rechtspraak.nl
Latest Posts in "Netherlands"
- Dutch Supreme Court Refers Key VAT Real Estate Questions to CJEU, Creating Market Uncertainty
- Dispute Over VAT on Final Payment for Business Transfer and Software Use Agreement, Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court 2025
- Supreme Court Confirms: No Destruction of Ruling; No Mediation or Foreign Establishment Proven
- General Court Excise T-690/24 (Kolinsen) – Judgment – Member State of arrival competent to levy excise duty in the event of irregularity detected on arrival
- Dutch Court Denies VAT Deduction for Crypto Platform Over Lack of Direct Service to Non-EU Clients
